By Lara Kiswani
Solidarity is not an act of charity. It is an act of unity between allies fighting on different terrains towards the same objective. The foremost of these objectives is to aid the development of humanity to the highest level possible.
— Samora Machel
That spirit of humanism and joint struggle is what birthed ethnic studies as an academic field. In their own words, the leaders in the 1968 Third World Liberation Front and Black Student Union strike at San Francisco State University declared, “We have decided to fuse ourselves with the masses of Third World people, which are the majority of the world’s peoples, to create, through struggles, a new humanity, a new humanism, a New World Consciousness, and within that context collectively control our own destinies. . . . Our essence is a New World Consciousness of oppressed peoples.”[1] Those peoples always included Palestinians. So why is the inclusion of Palestine in public education so controversial to decision-makers and political interest groups? Because, as the Arab American Studies Association puts it, “Palestine crystallizes for students questions of territory, memory, nationalism, settler colonialism, and dispossession; questions of race, class, gender, and sexuality; questions of solidarity, agency, interconnection, and transnationalism; questions of equity, dignity, and justice.”[2] Palestine animated the thrust of the decades-long struggle of ethnic studies itself.
Naturally, conservative and right-wing forces understand this new world consciousness, this solidarity and vision for humanity, as a threat. It is for that reason we find ourselves, time and time again, defending against attacks on public education and, more recently, attacks on ethnic studies. While ethnic studies has been under attack since its inception, today we are witnessing the latest manifestation of this struggle. At its core, the discipline situates education within a critical perspective of race and power. The same forces that attempted to thwart its successes in the 1960s are the ones challenging it today: those perpetuating the contradictions of our society—poverty, war, racism—rooted in imperialism and colonialism. As such, those of us continuing to fight for transformative education find ourselves in a perpetual state of proving we have a place in history and in the present not merely as victims but as protagonists of history and present-day struggles for social justice.
As educators and organizers engaged in this struggle, we simultaneously are in the process of reclaiming spaces taken from us while also creating new spaces of our own to win, shift, and build grassroots power. The struggle to advance an authentic ethnic studies curriculum across the state of California is one such example. In an attempt to tell the story of the fight for Arab American studies within the California Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum (ESMC) as a way to illustrate what is at stake within the terrain of education—more specifically, ethnic studies—and what is made possible through the collective organizing of people at the receiving end of racial capitalism.
California and the Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum
In 2016, after years of grassroots organizing by ethnic studies practitioners and community, the California State Assembly called for the creation of a state-approved high school Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum to be used by school districts across the state, and in September 2016, California Governor Jerry Brown signed Assembly Bill 2016 making it policy.[3] To complete this work, the California Department of Education convened an Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum Advisory Committee of practitioners to oversee its creation. They worked for eight months to produce an over-550-page draft document that provided a robust curriculum to be used in K–12 schools. Their work was clearly defined and included a system to receive public feedback along the way. At the eleventh hour in the summer of 2019, right-wing backlash ensued, pressuring California decision-makers to undermine the work of the committee. On March 18, 2021, the California State Board of Education rubber-stamped a whitewashed version of the ESMC that took particular aim at Palestinian people and history.
This right-wing backlash of 2019 specifically targeted the inclusion of Arab American studies in the Asian American studies section of the ESMC.[4] Led by pro-Israel interest groups and supported by state legislators, they ultimately succeeded in erasing the Arab American studies section. But the ongoing struggle waged to defend ethnic studies has overshadowed the battle that was lost with the ESMC.
Following the right-wing backlash, the Arab Resource and Organizing Center (AROC) partnered with the original writers of the ESMC to form the Save Arab American Studies coalition.[5] With dozens of youth, education, academic, and community organizations joining forces, the attempts to erase Palestine and Arab American studies were met with mass opposition. The Save Arab American Studies coalition launched with the understanding that the attack on Palestine was an attack on ethnic studies and built broad base support from other social and racial justice sectors in the United States. But this did not come easy. It required the hard labor of coalition-building to ensure that the divide-and-conquer tactics of our adversaries did not succeed. These tactics included attempts to pit other Southwest Asian and North African (SWANA) communities—particularly those whose voices were inadvertently not included in the draft—against one another, to misrepresent what was and wasn’t in the ESMC, and to attempt to redefine ethnic studies altogether.
The Attack on Arab American Studies
To unmask the nature of the attacks on the curriculum, ethnic studies practitioners and activists took on the task of political education and organizing. Why was Arab American studies included? And why was Arab American studies included within Asian American studies? What is Arab American studies, and how does it relate to other SWANA community stories and experiences? Is Arab American studies ethnic studies? Tackling these questions required an analysis of history and the ongoing sociopolitical experience of all those, including non-Arabs, whose roots lie in the Arab world and their ongoing social movements. The Arab community in the United States has a long history of organizing for change and working alongside other communities of color to build power to overturn the systems perpetuating forced migration, racism, and exploitation of all people. While very often in the crosshairs of racism and militarism and playing a prominent role in the US imperial imagination, Arab American stories and experiences are often invisible in classroom curricula.[6] And as a racialized community with roots spanning across West Asia and North Africa, Arab Americans have engaged in various struggles to ensure that our voices are included and accurately represented inside and outside of the classroom. From 2012 to 2019, youth leaders at the Arab Resource and Organizing Center conducted two youth-led research projects titled TURATH: Teaching Understanding and Representing Arabs Throughout History. As part of synthesizing the results of surveys on the representation of Arabs and Muslims in high school classrooms, they also analyzed textbooks. Unsurprisingly, the TURATH report published in 2020 found the overall experience of Arabs in the classroom to be directly correlated with the lack of curricula on Arabs or the content of the curricula—focused on the demonization of Arabs and Muslims. The report illustrates how only 2.3 percent of students surveyed learned about Arabs or Muslims at school.[7] It was for this reason AROC youth decided that ethnic studies and Arab American studies would be their primary campaign, coinciding with the struggle in California with the ESMC.
This coalition developed an organizing strategy that engaged dozens of California legislators while also building a grassroots movement across the United States, mobilizing close to one hundred thousand public comments to the California Department of Education in support of an authentic ethnic studies curriculum that included Palestine. The coalition built with Pacific Islander, Sikh, Armenian, and Iranian scholars and community to ensure that in the process of completing the curriculum other racialized communities and SWANA experiences were also included.[8] For far too long, we have witnessed the siloing of ethnic studies disciplines and departments in what scholar Dylan Rodríguez calls the “four food groups.”[9] We broke through those silos, eradicated fears, and built meaningful solidarity.
The founders of ethnic studies—veterans of the 1968 Third World Liberation Front and Black Student Union strike—condemned the revisions of the original ESMC curriculum and echoed that “as veterans of the student strike at San Francisco State and University of California, Berkeley, we stand solidly in support of the inclusion of Arab American Studies as part of the California Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum. It is a logical extension of what we fought for so many years ago: a relevant and liberatory education that will lead to a different world.” The founders of ethnic studies called on the need to redefine education, ground it, and make it accountable to liberation movements: educational self-determination through Third World studies. During the Save Arab American Studies campaign, this piece of history, that many take for granted, was crucial and served as a basis for solidarity and strategy in the face of mounting efforts to fracture our communities.
The California Teachers Association, one the largest unions in the state, opposed the revised curriculum.[10] Experts in the field, such as the Arab American Studies Association and the Association for Asian American Studies, opposed the revised curriculum as well.[11] In a powerful statement, scholars including Angela Davis, Cornel West, Marc Lamont Hill, Robin D. G. Kelley, and Barbara Ransby stated, “Many of us have long and distinguished careers teaching about Black and/or Ethnic Studies. While we are not all Californians, we all have a stake in the outcome of the Save Arab American Studies Coalition’s campaign for the integrity of Ethnic Studies curriculum.”[12] At various junctures, the coalition made significant advances, including having the California Department of Education agree to reinsert the Arab American studies section in Asian American studies in the ESMC. While this was a welcomed step taken by the department, they proved to fall short on their promises to stakeholders. The Department of Education not only relegated a whitewashed Arab American studies to an appendix alongside a pro-Israel, Zionist lesson plan but also gutted the entire Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum.
The grassroots movement for ethnic studies was being revived, strengthened, and emboldened, in part, due to right-wing backlash. The movement was clear on why this campaign was critical to the long arc of struggle against racism and colonialism. As Angela Davis puts it, “As is often the case when Black, Indigenous, and people of color gain power, attacks on Ethnic Studies have plagued the discipline since its earliest days. Today’s fight to maintain the integrity of the Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum is the next phase of the fight to defend Ethnic Studies.”[13]
The coalition organized, requested, and participated in endless meetings with legislators and the Department of Education. These meetings included scholars, heads of academic associations, ethnic studies practitioners, students, and community leaders. Many hours were spent defining what ethnic studies is and how teaching Palestine honors the fidelity of the discipline and supports California students. Repeatedly we witnessed these compelling arguments being met with skepticism and cynicism on the part of decision-makers. The irony of expert practitioners and the community having to prove to policymakers what is and is not ethnic studies, to make the case for the future of a self-determined discipline, was not lost on anyone. Ultimately, policymakers capitulated to right-wing interest groups. This culminated in the original writers publicly calling on the California Department of Education to remove their names from the document: “We request that our names be removed from the ‘Curriculum Acknowledgments’ section of the ESMC, effective today. We were not fully consulted throughout the process of the curriculum development and significant parts of the curricular text do not fully reflect the work of past or present Ethnic Studies teachers/educators. Ethnic Studies guiding principles, knowledge, frameworks, pedagogies, and community histories have been compromised due to political and media pressure. Our association with the final document is conflicting because it does not reflect the Ethnic Studies curriculum that we believe California students deserve and need.”[14] The final curriculum approved by the California Department of Education abandoned ethnic studies principles and pedagogy. The critical edge of ethnic studies, the analysis and critique of racism and other systems of oppression, was sanitized. Terms such as diasporic, familial, and marginalized were removed. Concepts such as hegemonic beliefs and practices were changed to beliefs and practices. Specific forms of oppression like patriarchy, cisheteropatriarchy, capitalism, ableism, and anthropocentrism were removed in favor of the phrase on multiple levels. And all mention of Palestine was erased. Further, embedded within the approved curriculum is a reference to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism—aligning with purposeful Zionist ethnonationalist colonial strategy of misrepresenting criticism of Israel as antisemitic.[15] What started off as an attack on Palestine became an all-out assault on ethnic studies. But this wasn’t merely an issue of collateral damage. It was the only logical outcome.
Building the Movement Toward a Liberatory Ethnic Studies
The organized attempts aimed at the erasure of Palestine and Arab American studies coalesced from a wide range of Zionist and other right-wing interest groups.[16] Arguably, their aim was to sanitize ethnic studies of any critique of race and power, not merely the erasure of Palestine. Fundamentally, it’s never about Palestine. Rather, it’s about what the movement for Palestinian liberation represents: the ongoing anticolonial struggle against US imperialism, racial capitalism, and global militarism; the decolonial liberatory potential of our movements; and the development of people-centered, multiracial democracy. It is about ethnic studies as a political project, not a fight for representation. In this sense, the fight for teaching Palestine is one with the struggle against the banning of books, the attacks on critical race theory, In Lak’ech, Black Lives Matter at School, and the fight for public education.
The struggle for Arab American studies and authentic ethnic studies in California began with and continues to be built on the fundamental principle of solidarity. The liberatory potential of education for working families, students, Black, Indigenous, and other communities of color is what is being threatened today. The movements that are birthed from them are both what is at stake and what we must all see as our path toward a liberatory distribution of social priorities. Fortunately, the solidarity that has been built during this struggle stands to outlast any policy or any shelved curricula and will shape the future of what is possible for our communities.
Following the failure of the California Department of Education to put forth an authentic ethnic studies curriculum in 2021, the Coalition for Liberated Ethnic Studies was formed. As communities organize to defend and protect the fidelity of ethnic studies, we are also building alternative vehicles for real ethnic studies curricula to be institutionalized across the United States: “Working collectively with grassroots movements, the Coalition for Liberated Ethnic Studies (CLES) lifts up principles, policies, practices, and pedagogies that center—the knowledge, narratives, experiences, and wellness of—Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPoC) communities so that liberation of all peoples and relations are realized. The coalition is composed of organizations and individuals engaged in work nationally, regionally and/or locally around Ethnic Studies, Black Lives Matter in Schools, Indigenous Studies and anti-racist, decolonial K-12 education.”[17] The Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum produced by the California Department of Education is not mandatory. Teachers and school districts have options, including the option to adhere to the fidelity of ethnic studies and use alternative curricula. Original writers of the curriculum have developed the Liberated Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum Consortium—a curriculum that adheres to the fidelity of the discipline.[18] This curriculum is being adopted district by district across California. Notwithstanding right-wing backlash, the efforts to challenge and overcome the whitewashing of ethnic studies are underway.
The Future of Teaching Palestine and Ethnic Studies
Today there is consensus across progressive communities that an attack on Palestine is an attack on all movements for justice. We can definitively say that consensus now extends through communities of antiracist teachers and scholars. The real work is building up the resources, developing strategy in the face of mounting attacks on public education, and coordinating across regions to ensure that educators and communities are working hand in hand to protect the terrain of public education at large.
We know that absent a systemic overhaul of our current Eurocentric K–12 curriculum, without individual teachers committed to providing alternative social-justice-oriented sources and curricula, without the power of teachers unions to defend their members and their members’ students, the experience of poor, working-class, Black, Indigenous, and other youth of color in public schools will continue to be alienating. A solution to the erasure of entire peoples, cultures, histories, and movements from education is ethnic studies.
With every step on this path communities of conscience walk together, we are reminded of the interconnectedness of our struggles—that our fight against exploitation is intertwined with our fight for self-determination, that the fight for democracy is also a fight for racial and economic justice, that the fight for climate justice is also a fight for public health, that our fight for Indigenous sovereignty is the fight against war and imperialism, and that the fight for liberatory education is the fight for our future potential.
What is possible today if we unite across communities to understand the domestic manifestations of fascism and white supremacy as inextricably linked to the Zionist colonial project? What type of united front does ethnic studies offer us in the fight against the right? What movement are we building today when we defend against the attacks on education? What politics and strategies are we advancing? How can we be sure not to leave women, trans, queer, Black, and Indigenous people, and Palestinians out of the movements against racism and fascism today?
The fight for ethnic studies and the Save Arab American Studies campaign remind us that it’s not only a moral imperative to build across movements, it’s necessary if we are to win. Just as the alliances of the elite make possible the suffering of so many, including our youth, our solidarity not only makes possible a new world but allows us the opportunity to continue practicing that principle together. The joint struggle of mass movements, the hard, unrecognized work of coalitions and base-building organizations, the thankless work more often than not done by women and gender nonconforming people have imagined and continue to make possible another world where people can live in their dignity and thrive toward that fullest potential that Samora Machel speaks of. During the creation of the Coalition for Liberated Ethnic Studies, Third World Liberation Front veteran Terry Collins passed on. His words inspired the organizers and remain a motto for the movement: “If you ain’t got principles, then you ain’t got nothing.”
Footnotes:
-
Gary Y. Okihiro, Third World Studies: Theorizing Liberation (Duke University Press, 2016), 18. ↑
-
“An Open Letter from Ethnic Studies Scholars in Support of Arab American Studies Curriculum in California High Schools (Updated January 21, 2021),” Arab American Studies Association, January 22, 2021, https://arabamericanstudies.org/advocacy/an-open-letter-from-ethnic-studies-scholars-in-support-of-arab-american-studies-curriculum-in-california-high-schools-updated-january-21-2021/. ↑
-
Jaclyn Zubrzycki, “California Governor Signs Law to Create First State Ethnic Studies Curriculum,” Education Week, September 16, 2016, https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/california-governor-signs-law-to-create-first-state-ethnic-studies-curriculum/2016/09. ↑
-
Dana Goldstein, “Push for Ethnic Studies in Schools Faces a Dilemma: Whose Stories to Tell,” New York Times, August 15, 2019, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/15/us/california-ethnic-studies.html#. ↑
-
Save Arab American Studies, https://savearabamericanstudies.org/. ↑
-
Nadine Naber, “Ambiguous Insiders: An Investigation of Arab American Invisibility,” Ethnic and Racial Studies 23, no. 1 (2000): 37–61. ↑
-
TURATH: Teaching Understanding and Representing Arabs Throughout History (Arab Resource and Organizing Center, 2020), http://savearabamericanstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/TURATH-Report-Representation-of-Arabs-in-High-Schools.pdf. ↑
-
Armenian-American Advancement Network, https://armenianamericanactionnetwork.org/teachingarmenianamerican. ↑
-
Amira Jarmakani, Christine Hong, Dylan Rodriguez, Alex Lubin, Keith P. Feldman, and Nathaniel Moore, “Arab American Studies, Palestine and the Fight for Ethnic Studies,” webinar from Arab Resource and Organizing Center, August 11, 2020, https://www.facebook.com/30192453920/videos/306470737262312. ↑
-
E. Toby Boyd, email to Yolanda Muños and Shanine Coats, Re: Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum, January 21, 2021, http://savearabamericanstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/21-Jan-CTA-Response-Third-Draft-ESMC.pdf. ↑
-
“An Open Letter from Ethnic Studies Scholars”; “AAAS Statement on the California Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum,” Association for Asian American Studies, December 2019, http://savearabamericanstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Assoc-for-Asian-American-Studies-Support-of-AAS.pdf. ↑
-
“An Open Letter to the CA Department of Education, State Superintendent Tony Thurmond, State Board of Education President Linda Darling-Hammond, and Secretary of State Shirley Weber,” March 2021, http://savearabamericanstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Open-Letter-to-SBE-and-CDE.pdf. ↑
-
Angela Davis, Nadine Naber, Andrew Jolivette, Jeff Duncan-Andrade, Russell Jeung, Theresa Montaño, Allyson Tintiangco-Cubales, Jason Ferreira, and Lara Kiswani, “The Fight for Ethnic Studies in CA,” webinar from the Arab Resource and Organizing Center, February 2, 2021, https://www.facebook.com/30192453920/videos/899256374162758. ↑
-
CDE Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum Advisory Committee Members of 2019 email to CA State Board of Education, Re: Remove Names from Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum, February 3, 2021, http://savearabamericanstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Letter-to-CDE-2.3.2021.pdf. ↑
-
“Backgrounder on Redefinition,” Palestine Legal, January 2020, https://palestinelegal.org/redefinition-efforts. ↑
-
Gabe Stutman, “Jewish Leaders Get Their Say on Controversial Ethnic Studies Curriculum,” Jewish News of Northern California, January 10, 2020, https://jweekly.com/2020/01/10/jewish-leaders-get-their-say-on-controversial-state-ethnic-studies-curriculum/. ↑
-
Coalition for Liberated Ethnic Studies, https://ethnicstudies-coalition.org/. ↑
-
“The Liberated Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum (LESMC),” Liberated Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum Consortium–LESMCC, https://www.liberatedethnicstudies.org/curriculum.html. ↑
Lara Kiswani is executive director of the Arab Resource and Organizing Center, a founding member of the Coalition for Liberated Ethnic Studies, and an educator and organizer from Beit Iksa and Aqir, Palestine, born and raised in the San Francisco Bay Area. Her work is rooted in internationalism, racial justice, and the transformative power of movement-building. Kiswani has developed and taught ethnic studies curricula in both academic and community settings and has led campaigns to expand and institutionalize ethnic studies in public education. She supports community-led organizing and advances grassroots internationalism that connects Arab and Muslim communities to broader movements for justice and self-determination.
